Running a background check on a prospective tenant is a crucial part of renting out a property. After all, before signing a lease, you need to confirm your would-be renter’s identity, their ability to pay rent, and whether they have a criminal or eviction history.
But running a background check on a tenant isn’t always as easy as it may seem. Different states have different laws in place governing the process, designed to protect tenants and landlords alike. So, no matter where you rent a property, it’s crucial to understand your local laws.
If you want to learn more about tenant background checks in your area, you’ve come to the right place. Here, you’ll find links to background check laws in all 50 states, as well as an overview of the tenant screening process, federal laws, and more.
Tenant Background Check Laws by State
alabama
alaska
arizona
arkansas
california
colorado
connecticut
D.C.
delaware
florida
georgia
hawaii
idaho
illinois
indiana
iowa
kansas
kentucky
louisiana
maine
maryland
massachusetts
michigan
minnesota
mississippi
missouri
montana
nebraska
nevada
new hampshire
new jersey
new mexico
new york
north carolina
north dakota
ohio
oklahoma
oregon
pennsylvania
rhode island
south carolina
south dakota
tennessee
texas
utah
vermont
virginia
washington
west virginia
wisconsin
wyoming
What is a tenant background check?
A tenant background check is a detailed screening process that landlords run before renting to a new tenant. The screening typically confirms a tenant’s identity and employment information, as well as their previous rental history and, if any, criminal background.
Landlords can run tenant background checks using digital software or specialized services tailored to leasing and rental property operations. Tenant screenings cost between $30 to $50 on average, but can exceed $70 if the landlord needs more detailed information.
Usually, landlords run background checks after receiving a tenant’s rental application and before deciding whether to agree to rent. However, some places require landlords to provide a conditional housing offer before screening. Landlords charge tenants for screening costs in most cases.
Why landlords use tenant background checks
Tenant background checks are an essential means for landlords to protect themselves. These screenings provide important information about whether a tenant may pose a threat to other renters on the property or struggle to pay rent on time each month.
Basically, landlords use the information obtained during background checks to inform the leasing process. For example, a landlord might charge a higher security deposit for a tenant with an eviction record, or deny housing to a tenant with relevant felony convictions.
As vital as background checks are, landlords also need to be aware of tenant protection laws across the country. These regulations vary by location, limiting the types of information landlords can obtain and use during the tenant background check process.
What Information Tenant Background Checks Typically Include
Since the goal of a background check is to find information on the tenant’s rental, criminal, and financial history, screening reports usually include these details:
Identity verification: Screening services use Social Security numbers to verify a tenant’s identity and confirm they are who they claim to be, reducing the risk of fraud.
Income verification: Based on tax documents and pay stubs, the screening service will confirm that the tenant can afford the rent. Typically, landlords look for a yearly income of at least three times the rent.
Credit history: Screening services also check for good credit history, comparing how much debt a tenant has against how much and how frequently they pay it off.
Criminal background: The tenant background check will reveal whether a tenant has any criminal history, such as property damage, domestic violence, or assaults.
Eviction history: The background check also provides information on all previous eviction actions—including filings that were later dismissed—based on public records.
Rental history: Beyond confirming whether a tenant was previously evicted, the background check also examines rent payment history and references from past landlords.
Federal Laws Governing Tenant Background Checks
In addition to state-level laws on tenant background checks, certain federal laws apply nationwide, protecting renters and restricting landlords’ actions to a degree.
Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA): Requires landlords to obtain a tenant’s written consent to run a credit check during the screening process. Landlords must also notify the tenant if their credit history results in a denial of housing and allow the tenant to dispute inaccuracies.
Fair Housing Act (FHA): Requires landlords to treat all applicants equally, regardless of protected characteristics such as race, religion, or marital status. The law prohibits landlords from denying housing based on these factors and imposes serious penalties for Fair Housing violations.
Consumer consent requirements: Before starting a tenant screening, landlords must inform renters that they are conducting a background check and that the information obtained may be used to deny housing. Tenants must also give written consent to the background check before the landlord can proceed.
Adverse action notice requirements: If the landlord asks for a co-signer, charges a higher rent or security deposit, or denies housing based on background check results, they must notify the tenant by providing an adverse action notice that includes a statement of the tenant’s right to dispute the action.
How to Run a Tenant Background Check
Before renting to a new tenant, landlords must know how to run a background check correctly and legally. Here’s what you’ll have to do:
- Collect a Rental Application
Once you list your vacant rental property as available, you should provide potential applicants with an easy way to apply. You can use traditional paper applications or send digital invitations to apply for a rental, ideally via email or property management software, to create clear records.
As part of the application process, you should ask the tenant to provide proof of their identity, their employment history, and references from previous landlords. Once you obtain this information, keep it well-organized so you can easily provide it to the screening platform of your choice.
2. Obtain Written Applicant Consent
Next, you’ll need to get the applicant’s consent to run a background check. Applicants must sign an official consent form that details the scope of the background check and its purpose: to determine whether the landlord will agree to rent to them.
As part of the written consent form, include a statement of the tenant’s rights if the screening turns up negative information that leads to a denial of housing. You can make the applicant consent form a part of the lease agreement or a standalone document.
3. Run a Credit and Background Screening Report
Once you have a complete application and signed consent, provide the tenant’s information to the screening service of your choice. This will give you access to credit reports, criminal history reports, and information on previous evictions, helping you make a more informed decision.
Platforms such as TransUnion, TurboTenant, TenantCloud, and more create comprehensive, highly accurate screening reports that landlords can trust during the rental application process. These services cost between $30 and $50, and fees can usually be passed along to the tenant.
4. Verify Income and Employment
If you’re verifying the tenant’s income and employment manually rather than relying on an automated service to do the legwork for you, you’ll need to double-check the tenant’s finances. Look over forms such as W-2s, 1099s, and bank statements or pay stubs.
For further verification, you may also want to contact the tenant’s employer directly if possible. However, if you use a comprehensive tenant screening service, you can leave this step to the software and only double-check the information for peace of mind.
5. Review Rental History and References
Nobody wants to rent to a tenant who will struggle to pay rent or, worse, may need to be evicted. Landlords should always review a tenant’s rental history, looking for red flags such as prior evictions or legal filings related to unpaid rent.
As part of the rental application process, you should ask tenants to provide references from previous landlords or property managers. You can contact these individuals to get additional verification of the tenant’s past behavior and rental history.
6. Evaluate Results Using Consistent Criteria
After receiving the screening report, you should have a more detailed picture of your next potential renter. Review the information in the report and keep a clear, systematic set of conditions in mind to determine whether to approve or deny housing.
This allows you to avoid Fair Housing Act violations while still securing the best tenant possible. Use the same standards for all applicants—no playing favorites or ignoring applications based on certain characteristics—and the background check will put you on a good footing to find a high-quality tenant.
7. Send an Adverse Action Notice if Needed
If you ultimately decide to deny the applicant rental housing, you may need to send them an adverse action notice. Did you choose another renter based on the tenant’s credit score? Or their criminal history? You’ll likely have to send them a notice explaining the reason.
The adverse action notice also allows the tenant to appeal your decision if needed. Notice requirements may vary by state, but under federal law, you’ll have to include the name and information of the service that provided the screening to allow for disputes.
States With Additional Tenant Screening Regulations
In addition to federal laws, some states impose additional limits on the tenant screening process. Read up on background check laws if you rent in one of the following states:
California
California caps tenant screening fees and requires landlords to make a conditional offer of housing before obtaining a criminal background check. Landlords must also provide copies of the screening report on request and send an adverse action notice if they deny the tenant’s application.
Washington
Before collecting any screening fees, landlords in Washington state must provide applicants with a written list of their screening criteria. Landlords also have to use an individualized assessment of an individual’s criminal history rather than issuing a “blanket ban” on anyone with a criminal record.
Oregon
In Oregon, landlords must provide tenants with a written receipt for screening fees. Additionally, landlords can consider only misdemeanor history from the previous 3 years and felony history from the previous 7 years. Last but not least, landlords can’t consider arrests that did not lead to convictions.
New York
Landlords in New York City cannot proceed with tenant screening and criminal history checks until after making a conditional housing offer. Landlords can also consider only misdemeanors from the previous 3 years and felonies from the previous 5 years, and cannot use “blanket bans.”
Massachusetts
Massachusetts landlords cannot reject applicants based on arrests that didn’t lead to convictions. Additionally, tenants can seal eviction records (sealed records cannot be considered during a background check), and landlords must provide the tenant with an adverse action notice if they choose to deny housing.
Tips for Running Fair and Effective Tenant Background Checks
As a landlord, you should be fair when screening new tenants, but you should also use the information responsibly to determine how to proceed with housing. Here’s what we suggest:
Apply consistent screening criteria: Use the same screening criteria for all tenants, regardless of external factors and characteristics protected by federal Fair Housing laws.
Always obtain written consent: Before conducting the screening, ensure the tenant signs a form that outlines the scope of the screening and how the information will be used.
Follow fair housing rules carefully: Never violate fair housing laws by showing preferential or discriminatory treatment to different applicants during the screening process.
Document your screening decisions: Keep detailed records of all screening decisions for new tenants, especially if you deny housing, to provide proof in the event of a complaint.
Avoid overly restrictive criteria: Use fair, but reasonable standards to find your next tenant, since highly specific criteria may cause you to deny a qualified rental applicant unfairly.
Use reputable screening providers: To ensure legal compliance and accuracy, always work with tenant screening companies that have strong reputations and operate within legal boundaries.
Keep applicant data secure: Instead of paper forms, use cloud-based services or property management software to store sensitive tenant information collected during the application process securely.
FAQs: Tenant Background Check Laws
Do landlords need permission to run a background check?
Yes, landlords must obtain tenants’ written permission before running a background check. The consent form should include information regarding the scope of the check and how the landlord will use the screening reports. The tenant must sign and date the form to confirm their consent.
How long does a tenant background check take?
Tenant background checks typically take 1 to 3 days to complete. However, depending on the service used, this timeframe can range from a few minutes to a week. Manual checks also take more time than automated checks conducted by software or professionals.
Can a landlord deny a tenant based on a background check?
Yes, landlords can deny a tenant based on information revealed by a background check. The landlord must issue an adverse action notice to the tenant, informing them of the denial, the reason, and the tenant screening service used in case the tenant wishes to dispute the decision.
What disqualifies someone from renting an apartment?
Certain relevant criminal acts, previous evictions, insufficient income, and lying on a rental application can all disqualify someone from renting an apartment. However, these conditions vary by state, so double-check your local laws to find out whether you have a valid reason to deny housing.