Over the last 10 days, we meticulously reviewed all of Cheyenne’s best property management companies based on fees, range of services and client satisfaction so that you can find the best property manager for your Cheyenne investment property.
Evernest
Evernest offers property management services to homeowner’s associations and residential properties throughout the Greater Cheyenne area.
- Address: 5420 Yellowstone Rd #2, Cheyenne, WY 82009
- Phone: 970-282-8281
- Service Types: Residential and HOA
- Years in Business: 14+ years
- Rentals Managed: 15000+
- Better Business Bureau: N/A
- Management Fee(s): 8% of monthly rent or $109 – $199 per month depending on the service plan
- Tenant Placement Fee(s): 50% of one month’s rent
- Lease Renewal Fee(s): $150 – $200 depending on the service plan
- Miscellaneous Fee(s): $149 Annual Inspection
Evernest works to provide stress-free management solutions for all types of residential properties and communities, handling all of the daily responsibilities of being a landlord to save you time, money, and energy. They pride themselves on their data-driven approach to the leasing and management processes, utilizing the latest software to accurately price your property, efficiently market your vacancy, schedule and coordinate showings, and screen prospective tenants for multiple points of background information so you can be certain that your property is in reliable hands. They’ll also facilitate the lease signing, collect and handle the security deposit, and perform a move-in inspection to document conditions before the tenancy begins. As part of their daily management, Evernest handles rent collection, annual inspections, preventative and emergency maintenance, tenant communication, lease renewals, evictions, and accounting. HOA management also includes financial management, board meetings, landscaping, common area maintenance, budgeting, legal compliance, and more.
All County Cowboy Property Management
All County Cowboy Property Management offers full-service residential property management throughout Cheyenne, Laramie, and the surrounding areas.
- Address: 409 S 4th St, Laramie, WY 82072
- Phone: 307-207-5100
- Service Types: Residential only
- Years in Business: 2+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: A
- Management Fee(s): 8 – 10% of monthly rent, depending on plan
- Tenant Placement Fee(s): 50% of one month’s rent with premium management or 100% of one month’s rent for tenant placement only
- Lease Renewal Fee(s): $300
All County Cowboy works to help you maximize your return on investment, offering full-service property management that also minimizes your expenses and ensures the protection of your investment at all times. They handle everything from leasing to evictions, so you can get back to enjoying life while they generate you passive income. Services begin with a complimentary rental analysis to accurately price your property and make suggestions on renovations that could boost your earning potential before preparing the property to be leased. As part of their leasing services, they take care of marketing your rental, showing it, screening potential tenants thoroughly, drafting a custom lease agreement with additional protections for you and your investment, and escrowing the security deposit. All County Cowboy’s daily management services include lease enforcement, rent collection, maintenance and inspections, lease renewals and evictions, and financial reporting, with income and expense statements generated monthly through the online owner portal to keep you informed on your investment’s performance at all times.
Legacy Property Solutions
Legacy Property Solutions offers comprehensive residential and commercial property management solutions for property owners and investors throughout the Cheyenne area.
- Address: 2409 E 15th St, Cheyenne, WY 82001
- Phone: 307-514-0110
- Service Types: Residential and commercial
- Years in Business: 4+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: N/A
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Legacy Property Solutions prides themselves on their skills, technology, knowledge, and over 60 combined years of property management experience, working to provide personalized management solutions that minimize your stress and maximize your ROI. Their services begin with a complimentary no-obligation consultation to help them gain a better understanding of your goals and needs and create a customized management plan. They also offer a rental analysis to accurately price your property and an initial inspection to document its condition for the security deposit. As part of their tenant placement services, Legacy markets your property extensively, conducts showings, screens prospective tenants, drafts the lease in compliance with Wyoming Landlord-Tenant law, and escrows the security deposit. During the lease, they answer maintenance requests swiftly, collect and disburse rent, communicate with tenants, conduct regular inspections, resolve tenant disputes, coordinate lease renewals and evictions, and provide a full suite of accounting services through the 24/7 owner portal, with monthly financial reports and annual tax statements available on-demand.
Lynn Manages Houses
Lynn Manages Houses manages residential properties for landlords, owners, and investors throughout Cheyenne.
- Address: 700 E 19th Street, Cheyenne, WY 82001
- Phone: 307-365-6850
- Service Types: Residential only
- Years in Business: 9+ years
- Rentals Managed: 250+
- Better Business Bureau: A+
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Lynn Manages Houses was built on a foundation of integrity, honesty, accountability, and transparency, and these core values guide every interaction you’ll have with their team. They pride themselves on not only offering excellent communication and services but also providing proactive and innovative property management solutions. Unlike other Cheyenne property management companies who pass you from department to department, when you partner with Lynn’s team, you’ll work directly with a dedicated manager who oversees the entire management process, allowing for greater oversight and consistency — and added comfort and satisfaction on your end. With their full-service management services, Lynn Manages Houses protects your legacy as well as your investment.
Crown Property Management
Crown Property Management provides real estate brokerage and property management services to residential and commercial property owners and investors in Cheyenne and the surrounding areas.
- Address: 2727 O’Neil Avenue, Cheyenne, WY 82001
- Phone: 307-635-5303
- Service Types: Residential and commercial
- Years in Business: 18+ years
- Rentals Managed: 600+
- Better Business Bureau: A
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Crown aims to help investors and property owners alike to maximize your ROI through a full suite of management and real estate services. For investors looking to build your portfolio, they provide a market analysis to identify unique investment opportunities, assist with the acquisition, and prepare your property to be leased. Existing property owners receive a complimentary rental analysis using comparable local properties already on the market to determine the right price point for your rental and identify any renovations or improvements that could add to your property’s value. Their leasing services handle advertising your property across multiple major rental websites such as HotPads and Zillow, online scheduling for self-guided showings, screening applicants thoroughly, and drafting the lease in compliance with Wyoming Landlord-Tenant laws. During the lease term, Crown provides tenants with an online portal for around-the-clock rent payments, maintenance requests, and communication, while owners have access to your own portal for viewing financial statements, tax documents, inspection reports, and more.
Kuzma Success Realty
Kuzma Success Realty provides Cheyenne property owners and investors with complete real estate solutions that include both brokerage and full-service management.
- Address: 603 East 17th Street, Cheyenne, WY 82001
- Phone: 307-638-8660
- Service Types: Residential and commercial
- Years in Business: 28+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: A+
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Kuzma Success Realty provides residential and commercial property management that includes tenant placement & daily management as well as real estate services to help you achieve your investment goals. Their lead broker has more than 35 years of real estate experience which helps to identify ideal investment opportunities so that you can achieve a return on investment sooner. This experience also helps to provide more effective pricing, marketing strategies, and vendor & maintenance relationships that translate to more profit for you. Kuzma Success Realty provides marketing of your listing, showings to interested applicants, screening for all potential tenants to ensure your property is in good hands, and custom leasing with full legal compliance so that you don’t have to worry about costly fines or lease issues. Day-to-day management takes care of addressing all of the tenant’s needs, upkeep of the property, and timely rent collection so that you can protect your investment, foster a positive landlord-tenant relationship, and enjoy consistent, reliable income.
Rock Solid Properties
Rock Solid Properties provides residential real estate brokerage and property management in Cheyenne and the surrounding areas.
- Address: 6161 Thunder Ridge Road, Cheyenne, WY 82009
- Phone: 307-274-8579
- Service Types: Residential only
- Years in Business: 5+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: N/A
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Rock Solid takes a client-first approach to real estate investment and property management, setting them apart from other Cheyenne property managers. Their brokerage services aim to make the investment process less intimidating with guidance provided throughout financing, the home search, the purchase negotiation, and more, even offering availability after-hours for any of your needs. They hold over 13 years of combined local market experience, which they put to use in not only the brokerage and management services they provide but also the relationships they build with vendors, clients, and tenants. While they do utilize a standardized pricing structure, they’re able to tailor to your individual needs so you don’t have to pay extra. Despite still being a somewhat newer company, they’ve earned the distinction of being a leading property manager in Cheyenne, ranking nearly 5 stars across all of their social channels and receiving high praise for their efficiency and transparency.
ERA Frontier Realty
ERA Frontier Realty offers a wide array of real estate and property management services for residential property owners throughout the Cheyenne area.
- Address: 2601 Central Ave, Cheyenne, WY 82001
- Phone: 307-638-1313
- Service Types: Residential only
- Years in Business: 39+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: N/A
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
ERA Frontier Realty has nearly 40 years of experience providing residential real estate brokerage and property management in Cheyenne and the surrounding areas, emphasizing customer service and the importance of building trusting long-lasting relationships. As your one-stop shop for all of your investment needs, they are dedicated to working with you closely to help you achieve your goals. Their extensive experience and local market knowledge enable them to provide premier services and maximize your return on investment without any increases in expenses or sacrifices in quality. Since their establishment in 1983, they have maintained a dedication to ensuring clients feel supported, involved, respected, and informed, whether they’re buying, selling, or leasing. As one of Cheyenne’s top property management companies, ERA Frontier Realty has earned praise for their kindness, professionalism, and quality.
Preferred Management, LLC
Preferred Management, LLC is a Cheyenne property management company serving residential and commercial property owners for more than 40 years.
- Address: 3124 Old Faithful Rd #100, Cheyenne, WY 82001
- Phone: 307-638-7232
- Service Types: Residential and commercial
- Years in Business: 42+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: A+
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Preferred Management provides full-service property management solutions for Cheyenne property owners, backed by more than 70 years of combined local market experience and over 40 years in business. Their proven management strategies take the stress out of leasing your property as they handle all daily operations, allowing you to be completely hands-off while they turn your investment into a passive income-generating machine. With a full-time maintenance staff, they’re able to ensure that your property is maintained in first-class condition, extending its lifespan and helping you retain long-term tenants. Clients praise Preferred Management for their professionalism, responsiveness, customer service, and helpfulness.
Real Property Management of the Rockies
RPM of the Rockies has over 30 years of experience as a full-service property and residential association management company in Cheyenne.
- Address: 2120 S College Ave Ste 5, Fort Collins, CO 80525
- Phone: 970-658-0410
- Service Types: Residential, commercial and HOA
- Years in Business: 30+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: N/A
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
RPM of the Rockies works with property owners and HOA boards to provide custom-tailored management solutions that save time, money, and stress. Their extensive local experience helps them to provide an accurate rental analysis that outlines earning potential and finds ways to increase it before beginning the leasing process. Both tenant placement and daily management are available separately or together, allowing you to get involved no matter how much experience or free time you have. Leasing takes care of all marketing, showings, screening, lease drafting, and security deposit handling while management addresses all tenant communications, collects rent, coordinates maintenance, and manages the lease to keep your property generating income. RPM of the Rockies also works with HOA boards to customize management services spanning finances, maintenance, administration, and legal divisions for an all-in-one solution. Their team can help with drafting a budget, coordinating & attending board meetings, handling maintenance & landscaping, providing owner support, building the community through events, and much more.
Superior Property Management of Wyoming & Colorado LLC
Superior Property Management of Wyoming & Colorado LLC is a full-service residential and commercial property management company serving Cheyenne and Northern Colorado.
- Address: 2232 Dell Range Boulevard Ste #116, Cheyenne, WY 82009
- Phone: 970-875-7312
- Service Types: Residential and commercial
- Years in Business: 1 year
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: A+
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Superior PM is a Cheyenne property manager aiming to provide cost-efficient, high-quality services that maximize your return on investment and minimize turnover. Their full-service management solutions span all aspects of property management from advertising to accounting and evictions, but they’ll work with you to create a customized plan to suit your individual needs. They believe in the importance of hands-on administration and open communication between owners, tenants, and property managers, priding themselves on their transparency and excellent customer service skills. Clients have given Superior PM a 4.6-star approval rating, praising their loyalty, reliability, knowledge, attention to detail, and professionalism.
BHJ Property Management, LLC
BHJ Property Management offers full-service residential and commercial real estate and property management in Cheyenne and the surrounding areas.
- Address: 101 S Main St, Sheridan, WY 82801
- Phone: 307-298-9955
- Service Types: Residential and commercial
- Years in Business: 116+ years
- Rentals Managed: Unknown
- Better Business Bureau: A+
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
BHJ PM prides themselves on their tenure as a Cheyenne property management company, having been a fixture in the community for over a century. As a full-service brokerage, they are equipped to handle all of your real estate needs, whether you’re looking to buy, sell, or lease a property in the Cheyenne real estate market. Their team holds combined decades of knowledge and experience, so when you partner with one of their seasoned agents, you can have peace of mind knowing your investment will be in professional hands. They also have experience as investors themselves, so they’ll work diligently to protect your bottom line and maximize your income so you can enjoy all of the benefits of property ownership stress-free. Proven by their 4.5-star approval rating, BHJ PM is committed to revolutionizing the property management industry through their commitment to positive change, setting the standard for the quality of care, consistency, and communication that clients deserve.
Bear Paw Realty
Bear Paw Realty provides full-service residential real estate brokerage and property management in Cheyenne and the surrounding areas.
- Address: 509 Persons Rd, Cheyenne, WY 82007
- Phone: 307-275-6409
- Service Types: Residential only
- Years in Business: 5+ years
- Rentals Managed: 300+
- Better Business Bureau: N/A
- Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing
Bear Paw Realty is dedicated to providing a smooth, successful property management or real estate experience that addresses all of your needs so you can enjoy passive rental income with complete peace of mind. Whether you’re buying, selling, or renting, their tailored approach and extensive experience within the Cheyenne real estate market guarantee the long-term success of your investment. And to ensure you get the most from your investment, they coordinate all maintenance and repairs with their network of budget-friendly contractors. As a leading Cheyenne property management company, Bear Paw Realty is committed to guiding you through every step of the investment process with professionalism and expertise, with their commitment earning them a nearly 5-star approval rating across their social channels.
