The 19 Best Property Management Companies in Fort Collins for 2022

The 19 Best Property Management Companies in Fort Collins for 2022

Last Updated: October 19, 2022

Over the course of two weeks, we compiled a list of all legally operating property managers in Fort Collins and compared their service offerings, pricing and feedback from actual Fort Collins landlords to identify the best of the best.

Evernest

Evernest is a residential brokerage, property, and HOA management company servicing the Greater Fort Collins area.

  • Address: 242 Linden St., Fort Collins, CO 80524
  • Phone: 303-768-8255
  • Service Types: Residential and HOA
  • Years in Business: 13+ years
  • Rentals Managed: 11000+
  • Better Business Bureau: N/A
  • Management Fee(s): 8% of monthly rent or $109 – $199 per month depending on the service plan
  • Tenant Placement Fee(s): 50% of one month’s rent
  • Lease Renewal Fee(s): $150 – $200 depending on the service plan
  • Miscellaneous Fee(s): $149 annual inspection fee

Evernest provides complete residential investment solutions and HOA management services that help to save you time, money, and stress. Their team includes real estate agents who can help identify unique investment opportunities and assist with acquiring them in a timely manner so that you can get to the rental market quicker for greater earning potential. Full-service management begins with a free rental report to outline expected earnings before transitioning to the tenant placement process where they create a listing for your property, market it through the MLS & online rental resources, screen applicants for a wide range of background information, and draft custom leases to ensure legal compliance for fewer headaches. Evernest’s day-to-day management includes all inspections, maintenance, rent collection, property bill payment, renewals, evictions, and reporting necessary to generate continuous rental income while HOA management services add Board coordination to provide administrative assistance, financial management, maintenance handling, owner relations, and community building services that work to add value to the community as a whole.

Go to website >>


RentPro Property Management

RentPro Property Management is a full-service property management company also offering brokerage services to owners and investors throughout Northern Colorado.

  • Address: 11 Old Town Square #250, Fort Collins, CO 80524
  • Phone: 970-900-1850
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 2+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: N/A
  • Management Fee(s): 9% – 13% of monthly rent depending on the service plan
  • Tenant Placement Fee(s): $300 – $600 depending on the service plan
  • Lease Renewal Fee(s): $150 – $300 depending on the service plan
  • Miscellaneous Fee(s): $85 inspections, $100 – $150 setup fee depending on the service plan

RentPro works with investors to find the Fort Collins property investment that helps you meet your goals, offering a market analysis as well as assistance throughout the acquisition process including budgeting and consultation. They also work with property owners to maximize your property’s ROI, starting with a rental analysis to identify the right price point for your property. As part of their leasing services, they handle marketing your vacancy, showing it to potential tenants, screening applicants thoroughly to ensure only high-quality tenants are placed, and drafting the lease in compliance with Colorado Landlord-Tenant laws. During tenancy, RentPro communicates with tenants, collects the rent, performs maintenance and inspections, coordinates evictions, and provides monthly financial statements through the online owner portal to keep you up-to-date on your investment’s performance.

Go to website >>


Henderson Management & Real Estate, LLC

Henderson Management & Real Estate provides Fort Collins investors and property owners with both brokerage and management solutions.

  • Address: 242 Linden Street PMB#7046, Fort Collins, CO 80524
  • Phone: 970-663-6311
  • Service Types: Residential and commercial
  • Years in Business: 28+ years
  • Rentals Managed: 1450+
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): 9% – 11% of monthly rent

Henderson Management has nearly 30 years of experience offering turnkey investment solutions that make it easy for you to get started with a new or existing rental property. Their real estate services highlight the best investment opportunities to consider based on market research and a cash flow analysis that outlines your earning potential so that you can put yourself in the best position to succeed. Once you’ve purchased the property, Henderson can help you fill your vacancy with a tenant through marketing of the vacancy, showings conducted by licensed agents, screening for information like rental or criminal history, and custom leasing with security deposit handling that ensures you do everything correctly and with full legal compliance. Daily management uses an online tenant portal to allow for anytime rent payment or maintenance requests that leads to happier tenants, better cash flow, and fewer damages throughout the lease in addition to their handling of renewals and evictions to make sure you’re continuously generating income as often as possible.

Go to website >>


Evergreen Property Management, Inc.

Evergreen Property Management, Inc. has over 30 years of experience providing residential property management services to clients throughout the Northern Colorado area.

  • Address: 1000 Driftwood Dr, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-226-5600
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 35+ years
  • Rentals Managed: 800+
  • Better Business Bureau: A
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Evergreen PM handles all aspects of property management, from advertising and leasing to move-out and evictions, working to protect your investment at all times. They pride themselves on effective marketing and tenant placement strategies that help them fill your vacancy more quickly with reliable, high-quality tenants that are likely to stay longer and cause fewer problems. Their leasing services include the creation of a listing for your vacancy, syndicating the listing on multiple platforms, showing the property to prospective tenants, screening applicants for a variety of background information, and drafting the lease agreement on your behalf. During tenancy, all maintenance requests are answered promptly, addressing issues before they can become costly or negatively impact your tenant’s quality of life. Evergreen PM’s daily management services include inspections, lease renewals and evictions, rent collection, and more.

Go to website >>


Touchstone Property Management LLC

Touchstone Property Management manages residential investment properties and HOAs in Fort Collins and the surrounding areas.

  • Address: 2850 McClelland Dr. Suite 1000, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-223-5000
  • Service Types: Residential and HOA
  • Years in Business: 32+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Touchstone PM can assist with generating rental income from your new or existing residential rental or work with your HOA’s Board to provide complete management solutions that add value for all parties. Rental property solutions begin with a free rental analysis to set income expectations and get the property rent-ready and include creation of a listing that will be marketed during the leasing process to reach a wide range of potential tenants. Leasing also includes showings, applicant screening for rental history and proof of income, custom lease drafting, security deposit handling, and other move-in procedures required to start the tenancy off right. Touchstone can also assume the role of the landlord to maintain your investment and address the needs of your tenant through services spanning rent collection, maintenance, lease management, and reporting while HOA services add on meeting coordination & attendance, budgeting, bookkeeping, dues collection, covenant enforcement, staffing, on-site services, landscaping, and many more solutions built to add value and save time & stress.

Go to website >>


Advantage Property Management

Advantage Property Management serves residential property owners throughout Fort Collins, offering property management and real estate services.

  • Address: 155 E Boardwalk Dr #400, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-214-8559
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 12+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Advantage PM offers an array of real estate services, from assisting with buying and selling properties to full-service property management. Investors can receive a market analysis to help you find your next Fort Collins rental property, while existing property owners are provided a rental analysis to identify the price point for your property that attracts tenants while maximizing your profits. As part of their leasing services, they handle marketing your vacancy, showing the property to prospective tenants, screening applicants for credit, rental, and criminal history, and drafting the lease in accordance with local and state laws. During tenancy, Advantage PM provides tenants with a 24/7 online portal for anytime rent payment, communication, and maintenance requests, while owners have access to your own portal for viewing financial statements and property reports. Daily management services also include inspections, lease renewals, eviction coordination, and more.

Go to website >>


Mountain-n-Plains, Inc.

Mountain-n-Plains is a full-service management company working with both investment properties and HOAs throughout the Greater Fort Collins area.

  • Address: 375 E Horsetooth Rd # 3100, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-221-2323
  • Service Types: Residential, commercial and HOA
  • Years in Business: 43+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Mountain-n-Plains has been providing complete management solutions for HOAs and rental properties for over 40 years, working to make it as simple as possible to get involved with an investment property. Whether you’re a new investor or have a vast portfolio, their services can help you to free up your time while adding additional value to your investments through a wide range of custom-tailored solutions spanning the entire rental process. To fill your vacancy, Mountain-n-Plains creates a listing for your property and markets it through all local & online rental syndications to reach as many potential tenants as possible so that they can show the property and collect applications to increase your potential tenant pool. Each applicant is screened for information like rental history, criminal history, proof of income, and more so that you can be certain your property is in good hands and a custom lease is drafted to adhere to local Landlord-Tenant and FHA laws to save you the stress of legal issues down the road. Mountain-n-Plains can also oversee the tenancy from start to finish, addressing all tenant communications and maintenance requests while collecting the rent, providing financial summaries for you to review on a regular basis, renewing the lease between terms at fair-market value, and evicting delinquent tenants to maintain your cash flow. For HOAs, they’ll work closely with the Board to identify and address the needs of the community with a custom management solution spanning administrative, financial, legal, maintenance, and owner support services.

Go to website >>


All Property Services, Inc.

All Property Services manages residential & commercial investment properties as well as HOAs throughout the Greater Fort Collins area.

  • Address: 1630 South College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-224-4446
  • Service Types: Residential, commercial and HOA
  • Years in Business: 36+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

All Property Services works with both residential & commercial property owners and HOAs to provide custom management solutions that save time, money, and stress. Both tenant placement and daily management are available for single-family, multi-unit, commercial, and mixed-use properties so that you can spend your time how you want to while they take care of everything necessary to generate income with your investment. Full-service management spans all marketing, showings, screening, leasing, security deposit handling, maintenance, rent collection, and lease management so that you can be entirely hands-off throughout the whole process while enjoying the passive income All Property Services’s managers generate for you with the peace of mind provided by over 35 years of market experience. They can also coordinate with your Board to provide a variety of tailored services to your HOA, including recordkeeping, budgeting, dues collection, maintenance & landscaping, project oversight, renovation services, covenant enforcement, owner relations, and much more.

Go to website >>


Stegner Property Management

Stegner Property Management provides full-service management services to residential property owners and investors in Fort Collins and the surrounding areas.

  • Address: 1020 Luke St. Suite B, Fort Collins, CO 80524
  • Phone: 970-420-2191
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 14+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Stegner eliminates the hassles of managing your property on your own, taking care of all of the day-to-day responsibilities of being a landlord so you don’t have to. To help you get started earning, they’ll perform a free rental analysis that determines your expected monthly income and identifies any renovations that could add to your property’s value. Once your property is ready to be leased, they will market and advertise your vacancy, answer rental inquiries, conduct showings for interested applicants, screen potential tenants for credit, rental, and criminal history, and draft the lease in accordance with local and state laws. During the lease term, Stegner coordinates and oversees maintenance, conducts annual inspections, collects rent, enforces the lease, and processes lease renewals and evictions as needed. Accounting services are also provided through the 24/7 online owner portal, keeping you informed at all times.

Go to website >>


Kevco Real Estate Investments & Property Management

Kevco Real Estate Investments offers brokerage and property management services for all kinds of residential rental properties in Fort Collins.

  • Address: 1124 W Mulberry St, Fort Collins, CO 80521
  • Phone: 970-419-8881
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 13+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Kevco Real Estate can help you find a new investment property through brokerage services, assist with filling your vacancy, and oversee the daily management of your rental property to generate passive rental income you can enjoy without getting your hands dirty. Their real estate team searches the market for unique investment opportunities that offer a positive ROI as a rental property, allowing you to put yourself in the best position to succeed along with preparation through cost-effective improvements or maintenance that gets it rent-ready. Once prepared, Kevco transitions you to the tenant placement process where they market your vacancy through the MLS and online rental sites like Zillow or Trulia in order to reach a wide range of potential tenants so that you can collect more applications to screen for higher quality tenant candidates. Screening and custom lease drafting ensures your property is in good hands and you’re protected as much as possible for a stress-free tenancy that benefits from Kevco’s diligent daily management that takes care of collecting the rent, coordinating maintenance, renewing the lease at fair-market values, and evicting tenants who break the lease so that your cash flow is restored ASAP.

Go to website >>


Real Property Management of the Rockies

Real Property Management of the Rockies manages both investment properties and HOAs throughout Fort Collins and the surrounding areas.

  • Address: 2120 S College Ave Ste 5, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-658-0410
  • Service Types: Residential, commercial and HOA
  • Years in Business: 9+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

RPM of the Rockies works to maximize your profitability, minimize your expenses, and relieve you of the stress of being a landlord through full-service management solutions for residential properties, commercial buildings, and HOAs. service begins with a free rental analysis to assess your potential income rate with and without cost-effective improvements along with providing a custom quote for just the services you need. Tenant placement with RPM allows you to hand off the property to their team to create a listing, market it, show the property, and screen potential tenants for rental history, criminal history, and proof of income before securing your chosen tenant in a custom-drafted lease that ensures legal compliance at all stages for your peace of mind. RPM of the Rockies can also assume the role of the landlord during the lease term to address the needs of both the tenant and property, working to communicate with the tenant and field maintenance requests through the tenant portal, collecting rent through the portal, renewing leases between terms, evicting delinquent tenants, and generating financial reports to keep you informed. HOA management offers many of the same services along with common area maintenance, meeting coordination & attendance, full bookkeeping, budgeting assistance, dues collection, maintenance & upkeep, project oversight, owner relations, and a variety of other services spanning any and all aspects of the association management process.

Go to website >>


The Source Property Management

The Source Property Management works with residential and commercial property owners and investors throughout Northern Colorado.

  • Address: 375 E. Horsetooth Rd. Bldg 1 Suite 201, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-797-3383
  • Service Types: Residential and commercial
  • Years in Business: 4+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

The Source PM works with investors and property owners to help you meet your real estate investment goals, creating a custom-tailored plan to meet your needs and maximize your profits so you can enjoy all of the benefits of property ownership without the time commitment. To get started, they’ll perform a rental analysis to determine your expected monthly income, make recommendations on renovations that could add to your property’s value, create a marketing plan, and prepare your property to be shown and leased. As part of their leasing services, they will market your vacancy, conduct showings with licensed agents, screen potential tenants for background information, draft a legally-compliant lease, and handle all move-in procedures. Daily management with The Source PM includes maintenance coordination and oversight, periodic inspections, rent collection, tenant communication, and financial reporting, with profit/loss statements generated monthly.

Go to website >>


Trilogy Property Management, LLC

Trilogy Property Management, LLC serves residential property owners and investors in Fort Collins and the surrounding areas.

  • Address: 155 E Boardwalk Dr Ste 426, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-404-1767
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 6+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Trilogy PM works to maximize your return on investment through their full-service property management. Services begin with a complimentary rental analysis to accurately price your property based on comparable local properties and current market conditions. Once your property is ready to be leased, they’ll handle marketing it extensively, showing it to potential tenants, screening applicants thoroughly, and preparing and executing a custom lease agreement with additional protections afforded for you and your investment. Not only do they guarantee to find you a tenant within 2 weeks, but all approved tenants are also guaranteed for 120 days or they will be replaced at no additional cost to you. During tenancy, Trilogy PM answers maintenance requests, communicates with tenants, collects rent, and more, with a number of accounting services available on-demand through the online owner portal.

Go to website >>


Faith Property Management

Faith Property Management specializes in residential property and association management backed by over 35 years of Fort Collins market experience.

  • Address: 300 E. Boardwalk Unit 6B, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-377-1626
  • Service Types: Residential and HOA
  • Years in Business: 36+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Faith PM works with residential property owners and investors to provide complete rental property solutions as well as HOA Boards to offer custom-tailored solutions aimed at adding value to their community. New or existing rentals can get a free assessment to set expectations for earning potential and help establish a budget before the leasing process begins to find tenants to place in your vacancy. They’ll take care of everything it takes to quickly find a high-quality tenant and initiate the tenancy with a rock-solid lease to protect you as much as possible so that you can begin earning income sooner. During the lease term, Faith PM acts as the sole point of contact for the tenant so that you can be hands-off and avoid having to worry about chasing down rent or addressing emergency maintenance at all hours of the night. Renewals, evictions, and reporting are also included for investment properties while HOA management adds on Board coordination to address budgeting, dues collection, vendor negotiations, staffing, on-site upkeep, maintenance coordination, covenant enaction & enforcement, owner support, community activities, and much more.

Go to website >>


CASA Property Management, LLC

Casa Property Management is a complete management company working with residential properties, commercial properties, and HOAs throughout Fort Collins.

  • Address: 2580 E Harmony Rd. Suite 201, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-412-3812
  • Service Types: Residential, commercial and HOA
  • Years in Business: 1+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A-
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Casa PM specializes in management services for both investment properties and residential communities that saves you time and stress while adding value to your portfolio or community as a whole. Their services span all leasing and daily management required to get started with an investment property with additional renovation and staging services that can help to lease your property quickly for greater profitability along with agent-assisted showings. Casa PM screens all applicants to make sure your property is going to be taken care of and that your income remains consistent while a custom lease protects you from costly legal issues down the road. Day-to-day management prevents you from being on-call for any tenant needs or property issues that arise for stress-free passive income generation. Casa collects rent & disburses it to you, coordinates inspections, addresses maintenance, renews leases between terms at the current market values, processes evictions in a timely manner with full legal compliance, and generates financial summaries to keep you informed at every stage. HOA management works closely with your Board to create custom solutions that add value to your community and simplify the duties of the Board for a better experience for all members. They can assist with maintenance, financial management, owner relations, legal compliance assurance, and a variety of other services tailored specifically for your needs.

Go to website >>


Trademark Property Management Group, Inc.

Trademark Property Management Group works with residential & commercial rental properties as well as HOAs to provide complete management for the Greater Fort Collins area.

  • Address: 100 North Mason Street, Fort Collins, CO 80524
  • Phone: 970 237-6969
  • Service Types: Residential, commercial and HOA
  • Years in Business: 4+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: C+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Trademark PMG aims to maximize your profitability while minimizing the time investment & stress associated with being a landlord through their full-service management solutions. Working with both residential and commercial properties, they can address your full portfolio at once with services that allow you to hand your entire portfolio over to them so that the only thing you have to worry about is figuring out how to spend your newfound free time. Services span both tenant placement and daily management with legal compliance and profitability emphasized at every stage. Trademark’s collection of solutions includes marketing, screening, lease drafting, security deposit handling, maintenance, rent collection, renewals, and evictions with an online tenant portal for timely communication and owner portal for on-demand financial reports. They also support HOAs with custom management solutions that save the Board time and stress while working to achieve a higher quality standard throughout the community by implementing best practices that improve cash flow, lower costs, and offer better support for the owners that give value to the HOA.

Go to website >>


All County Fort Collins

All County Fort Collins manages residential properties for clients in Fort Collins and the surrounding area.

  • Address: 1027 W Horsetooth Rd Suite F208, Fort Collins, CO 80526
  • Phone: 970-825-1000
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 7+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

All County Fort Collins works to maintain a high occupancy rate for your property, effectively placing high-quality, long-term tenants and keeping your profits consistent. Their services start with a complimentary rental evaluation to ensure you get the most for your investment before they prepare it to be leased. Leasing services offered include marketing your vacancy on their website as well as multiple other major rental websites, showing the property to interested applicants, screening potential tenants thoroughly for multiple points of background data, preparing and executing the lease agreement in compliance with Colorado Landlord-Tenant laws, and escrowing the security deposit. During the lease term, All County Fort Collins enforces the lease, performs routine maintenance and inspections, collects the rent, processes lease renewals and evictions, and provides online access to monthly income and expense reports so you can keep track of profit/loss and stay informed.

Go to website >>


Drake Manor Management

Drake Manor Management is a full-service brokerage & management company working with both residential and commercial properties in Fort Collins and the surrounding areas.

  • Address: 2821 Remington St. Suite 100, Fort Collins, CO 80525
  • Phone: 970-493-4052
  • Service Types: Residential and commercial
  • Years in Business: 25+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

Drake Manor Management works to provide complete investment solutions that allow you to maximize your profitability from any stage of the process. They’ll assist with finding a new property through market research & analysis, buying assistance, and preparation services while also providing a rental analysis to existing property owners so that you can decide whether leasing your property is right for you. Drake Manor Management both places high-quality tenants in your property and oversees the tenancy so that you can sit back and relax while they generate income for you to enjoy through comprehensive services spanning marketing, showing, screening, leasing, and security deposit handling before the tenancy and then maintenance, rent collection, and leasing during the lease term. This allows them to generate rental income while protecting your investment for minimal value loss and providing a positive tenant experience that keeps them paying rent & signing longer leases for fewer headaches.

Go to website >>


TBC Property Management

TBC Property Management specializes in residential property management services for both single-family and multi-unit housing in Fort Collins.

  • Address: 3021 S Taft Hill Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80526
  • Phone: 970-224-0852
  • Service Types: Residential only
  • Years in Business: 6+ years
  • Rentals Managed: Unknown
  • Better Business Bureau: A+
  • Management Fee(s): Contact for pricing

TBC PM works with residential property owners to provide stress-free, cost-effective management solutions tailored to your specific needs so that it’s easy to begin earning rental income. They’ll provide an initial consultation to outline expected earning potential and help prepare the property with cost-effective renovations before transitioning to leasing to fill your vacancy. This includes marketing of the listing through local & online rental resources, showings conducted by agents who “sell” your property to potential tenants, screening applicants for things like rental history or proof of income,and custom lease drafting to maximize your protection. TBC PM’s daily management is equally comprehensive, using an online tenant portal to allow for anytime rent payment for better cash flow and maintenance requests that keep your property from experiencing costly damages. All renewals and evictions are addressed as needed to maintain your cash flow and reports are generated monthly & annually to simplify the financial side of things and keep you informed at all times without being involved.

Go to website >>