Property Management
in Milwaukee, WI

Top 25 Property Management Companies

Companies who earn the iPropertyManagement seal of approval have demonstrated a high standard of excellence for both owners and tenants in the field of property management.

milwaukee-wi-badge

License #: 700270

Bender Property Management

#1 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

No Reviews Found

414-535-9992
6622 W Fond Du Lac Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53218
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1995
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers property management services for rental homes, apartments, condominiums, and office buildings.
  • Property management includes filling vacancies, screening tenants, collecting rent, handling evictions, and bookkeeping with bill paying such as paying taxes, water, and insurance bills.

License #: ?

Pennybag Property Management

#2 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

262-719-1332
3728 N 36th St, Milwaukee, WI 53216
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers commercial and residential property management services.
  • Provides maintenance, repairs, renovations, and general construction.
  • Renovations include kitchens, living rooms, and bathrooms.
  • Construction services include build-outs, remodeling, replacing siding, painting, plumbing, and electrical work.
  • Maintenance services include snow removal, gutter cleaning, and general handyperson work

License #: 834967

Eastmore Real Estate Management, Inc

#3 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-961-1822
3287 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in residential rental properties.
  • Manages over 40 historic properties that have been renovated.
  • Serves the areas of Milwaukee’s East Side, near UW-Milwaukee, Downtown, Shorewood, and Whitefish Bay.
  • Property management includes advertising, tenant screening, lease signing, rent collection, bookkeeping, maintenance (including 24/7 emergency response), and evictions as needed.
  • Uses Appfolio software to provide the tenants with an online portal to pay rent and request help, and to provide the owner with information about the rental property and monthly statements.

License #: 834512

Milwaukee Property Management

#4 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 3 Reviews Show all

414-312-5001
611 W National Ave , #325 Milwaukee, Wi. 53204
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Manages commercial, vacation, and residential rental property as well as homeowners’ and condominium owners’ associations.
  • Property management includes advertising, tenant screening, handling tenant relations, rent collection, property maintenance, and financial reporting.

License #: ?

Schulhof Property Management LLC

#5 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-933-1211
825 N 16th St, Milwaukee, WI 53233
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: A+
Since 1997
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in managing apartment complexes near the Marquette University campus.

License #: 937268

Structure Property Management

#6 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

Based on 2 Reviews Show all

414-882-8777
804 E Wright St, Milwaukee, WI 53212
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2013
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Property management services include property evaluation, marketing, tenant screening, move-in/move-out inspections, leasing, maintenance, repairs, landscaping, snow removal, remodeling, legal support, evictions, financial tracking, and reporting.
  • Uses Buildium Building Manager software to provide web portals for the tenants and owner.

License #: ?

GatoCity LLC

#7 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-403-8645
610 E Pleasant St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in properties located in Milwaukee’s East Side, Bay View, Cudahy, New Berlin, Wauwatosa, and West Allis.
  • Uses Appfolio software to provide the tenants with an online portal for rent payments and maintenance service requests and to provide the owner with an easy way to obtain information about the rental property and monthly statements.

License #: ?

Jomela Properties

#8 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-442-1700
5601 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2003
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in managing single-family rental homes, duplexes, and apartment building complexes.
  • Uses Appfolio software to provide the owner with information and the tenants with an online portal for rent payments and maintenance service requests.

License #: 2963

Benkowski Builders

#9 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 1 Reviews Show all

414-762-5400
1111 Milwaukee Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1953
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in commercial buildings and residential rental properties including single-family homes, townhouses, apartments, and heritage properties.
  • Serves the communities of South Milwaukee, Cudahy, Greendale, Kenosha, Milwaukee, Oak Creek, and Racine.

License #: 937517

Citywide Rentals

#10 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-269-6446
9919 W Lisbon Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53222
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since 2013
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Property management services include competitive rental rate setting, vacancy advertising, showings, applicant screenings, lease signing, inspections, fee and rent collection, property maintenance, and evictions.
  • Uses Appfolio software to provide the owner with a web portal to get reports and information. Also provides the tenants with an online portal for rent payments and maintenance service requests.

License #: ?

Sidello Property Services

#11 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 1 Reviews Show all

414-482-7476
4864 S 10th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1995
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers property management services for residential and commercial properties including office buildings, industrial, parking lots, laundromats, and self-storage facilities.

License #: ?

Dominion Properties

#12 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 9 Reviews Show all

414-264-5901
2025 N SUMMIT AVE MILWAUKEE WI, 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2000
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in downtown and East Side Milwaukee apartment buildings.
  • Works with investors to develop and rehab historic buildings.

License #: 700381

NAI MLG Commercial

#13 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 3 Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-347-9400
757 N Broadway #700, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Areas Served Milwaukee
51-200 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1987
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • This is a private commercial real estate investment fund that specializes in managing multifamily properties, industrial properties, retail stores, and commercial office buildings.

License #: 9852

Ogden & Company, Inc

#14 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-276-5285
1665 N Water St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee, Wauwatosa, WI, Chilton, WI,Franklin, WI, Mesa, AZ
51-200 employees BBB: A+
Since 1929
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers property management for commercial properties, and multifamily residential properties such as apartment complexes, condominiums, and homeowners associations.
  • Property management services include accounting, budgeting, leasing, handling communications, maintenance, landscaping, snow removal, enforcing lease compliance, handling tenant relations, maintains records, managing operations, organizing service contracts with bid proposals to improve cost savings with bulk purchasing, contractor supervision, receivership management, site inspections, legal compliance, and transition management.
  • Uses Yardi software for accounting.
  • Financial services include monthly statements that show receipts, disbursements, income, expenses, cash on hand, reserve account balances, and current liabilities.
  • Budgeting includes preparing the annual budget and the monthly reports of budget versus actual expenses.
  • Leasing services include leasing of residential apartments or townhouse units, negotiating leases, and preparing lease documents.
  • Maintenance services include a 24/7 emergency response system and supervision of the maintenance of mechanical systems within the property such as HVAC, electrical, plumbing, and others. Supervises contractors with an inspection of completed work by the property manager before invoices are paid.
  • Receivership management includes occupancy verification, tenant compliance, property preservation, client communications, leasing services/marketing, obtaining broker price opinions, and sales coordination.
  • Transition management to provide property management services includes conducting audits of the financial data, lease information, and service contracts. Transition management also includes reviewing building information, notifying tenants and vendors, and conducting property inspections. Works with personnel and emergency response teams and closely with the owner to make sure the transition goes smoothly.

License #: 700458

Pentagon Property Management

#15 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-225-5800
732 N Jackson St # 300, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2011
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in full-service commercial, industrial, and retail property management.
  • Offers leasing, accounting, construction, maintenance, and operational management.

License #: 14224

Bieck Management

#16 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 12 Reviews Show all

414-961-7400
5205 N Ironwood Rd # 201, Milwaukee, WI 53217
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1977
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers property management services for commercial properties, multifamily apartment complexes, and mobile home parks.
  • Besides Milwaukee, also serves the communities of Bayside, Bellevue, Bonduel, Cudahy, Glendale, Grafton, Hartland, Menasha, Menomonee Falls, New Holstein, Oak Creek,
  • Pewaukee, Plymouth, Racine, Sheboygan, Shorewood, St. Francis, Union Grove, Waukesha, Wauwatosa, West Allis, Whitefish Bay, and Whitewater.
  • Has its own in-house maintenance division that provides the following services: 24/7 emergency response, plumbing, electrical repairs, painting, drywall repair, deck repair and replacement, lock replacement, window repairs, masonry, foundation work, heating and air conditioning repairs, and construction build-outs.
  • Uses Rent Manager software to provide web portals for the owner and tenants.

License #: 700045-91

MPI Property Management

#17 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 8 Reviews Show all

414-933-2700
6700 W Fairview Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53213
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: A+
Since 1978
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in residential rental properties including single-family homes, individual condominiums, duplexes, and larger multifamily complexes.
  • Manages over 1,100 units.
  • Serves Milwaukee and the communities of Shorewood, Whitefish Bay, Wauwatosa, Bayview, West Allis, Cudahy, Glendale, Greenfield, Greendale, Brown Deer, South Milwaukee, Brookfield, Oak Creek, New Berlin, Franklin, Mequon, Pewaukee, Somers, Caledonia, Kenosha, Pleasant Prairie, Muskego, Sussex, Hartland, Menomonee Falls, Oconomowoc, Germantown, Wales, Cedarburg, Grafton, Waukesha, Racine, and Butler.
  • The leasing placement fee is $23 per week for advertising. There is no lease renewal fee.
  • Property management services are $80 per month or 7% of the monthly collected rent. These services include finding qualified renters for vacancies, in-person showings (six days per week), collecting rent, and handling accounting.
  • Accounting services include preparing monthly statements with year-end financial reports for the tax return, bill paying, and direct deposits made of net rental proceeds to the owner’s bank account.
  • Has an in-house maintenance/repair staff. Offers a discount on maintenance services ($45 per hour) if the property is managed. Offers maintenance services separately, even if the property is not managed. These services include cleaning, hauling, painting, drain cleaning, electrical work, plumbing, carpentry, roofing, siding repair/installation, HVAC repairs, and general handyperson work.
  • Manages real estate owned (REO) foreclosed properties. These services include cleaning, securing, and locking property at the time of taking possession, research and mitigation of any fines and violations with municipalities, condominium associations, or property owners’ associations.
  • Offers a cost-estimation and bidding process using licensed and insured contractors for construction, and rehab. Offers supervision services for needed repairs to bring a property into compliance and get it ready for the rental market.
  • Handles regular upkeep and maintenance while renting the investment property making a sale easier. Markets properties for sale to known investors and through the MLS.
  • Eviction support is offered if needed. Offers eviction-only service for $350 in Milwaukee County, even if the property is not managed.

License #: ?

ABC Management Inc

#18 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 2 Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-225-3100
621 E Pleasant St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since 2008
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Manages over 600 units of multifamily properties.

License #: ?

Bell Property Management Inc

#19 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

No Reviews Found

414-332-1117
2545 N Maryland Ave #102, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since 1998
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in multifamily apartment complexes.

License #: 700477

TEAM Management, LLC

#20 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

No Reviews Found

414-273-8326
3816 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Manages residential and commercial rental properties in Manitowoc, Dane County, and Milwaukee County.
  • Specialized in managing properties designated for affordable housing either through Section 8 or Section 42.
  • Accounting services using Yardi software include monthly financial statements along with budgeting reports.
  • Provides a full range of maintenance services and after-hours emergency response.
  • Resident leasing uses rigorous tenant applicant screening criteria.
  • Ongoing management includes compliance monitoring for Section 8 and IRS Sec. 42.

License #: ?

MKE PM

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-534-9391
2510 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Manages residential and commercial properties.
  • Offers a tenant screening-only service which includes listing by the agent, lease preparation, a link to an online landlord/tenant handbook, and processing tenant applications/screening for a fee.
  • Offers an investor management service which includes listing by the agent, lease preparation, a link to an online landlord/tenant handbook, and processing tenant applications/screening for a fee. Maintains the lease file archive and provides consultative services and vendor resources to the owner.
  • Management fees are based on collected rent income.
  • Offers full-service property management, which includes online marketing through thousands of rental sites. Tenant screening services include a credit report, criminal background screening (including sex offender databases), employment verification, rental history, and a search for prior evictions.
  • Handles the preparation of all lease paperwork.
  • Collects deposits, rents, and fees with online payment processes for both tenants and the owner, with a direct deposit option for the owner.
  • Conducts annual inspections as well as move-in and move-out inspections with photos/video.
  • Provides online owner and tenant portals and 24/7 emergency maintenance call center.
  • Offers a portfolio of licensed, bonded, and insured vendor resources, including complete property restoration and rent-ready services.
  • Accounting services include monthly and annual owner financial statements and annual owner’s tax statements.
  • Offers eviction services as needed.

License #: 936820

Siegel-Gallagher Management

No Reviews Found

No Reviews Found

414-270-4100
252 E Highland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee, Chicago, IL
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1995
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Manages commercial properties, marina, airports, campus facilities, and multifamily residential properties.
  • Commercial property management includes marketing, repositioning, leasing, strategic planning, site development, financial analysis, budgeting, tenant relations, demographic analysis, pro-forma analysis, vendor management, maintenance, energy audits, bulk purchasing of supplies at a discount, cash management, and lease negotiations.
  • Residential services include start-up, financial, engineering, asset management, operational management, leasing, and marketing.
  • Start-up services include a property condition assessment, a lease review, bank account set-up, financial reporting and transfer set-up, and a work-order-tracking system set-up.
  • Financial services include rent collection, invoice payments, and annual budgeting.
  • Engineering services include a 24-hour emergency response system and energy audits.
  • Asset management includes an existing market condition analysis, leasing oversight, and solutions-based value enhancement.
  • Property management services include staffing, benchmarking, subcontracting/vendor management, utility analysis, handling tenant/owner relations, and monthly property inspections.
  • Leasing and marketing services include developing a lease-up strategy, ILS management, fair housing training, market analysis, strategic website design, search engine optimization (SEO), reputation intelligence/management, social media, outreach marketing, and branding.

License #: ?

The Management Group

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-444-1800
7430 West Harwood Avenue, Suite 200Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Areas Served Milwaukee,Wauwatosa, WI
? BBB: A+
Since 2008
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Specializes in managing residential rental income properties including single-family homes and multifamily apartment communities.
  • The Management Group is under review by the Better Business Bureau for “a pattern of complaints that involve services, which are paid for, but not delivered to the paying customers.” On May 14, 2020, the BBB accreditation was revoked. The website may no longer be active.

License #: 701546

Westbrook Management

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-270-0300
622 N Water St # 200, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
51-200 employees BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers property management services for affordable housing, apartment complexes, condominiums, and commercial properties.

License #: ?

Zilber Limited

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-274-2400
710 N Plankinton Ave # 1200, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Areas Served Milwaukee
51-200 employees BBB: A+
Since 1948
Residential
Commercial
Hoa
  • Offers management and development of residential, commercial, and light industrial properties.
  • The majority owner of Zilber Ltd. is the Joseph and Vera Zilber Charitable Foundation, Inc. This is a private, non-profit organization working to improve the well-being of individuals, families, and neighborhoods.

Milwaukee vs Nearby Cities

Real estate prices in Milwaukee are surprisingly affordable, especially when compared to home prices in many surrounding cities. Positioned on the eastern coastline of Wisconsin, this city offers a median listing price below $150,000 much of the time. Compare that to a median listing price close to $250,000 in Waukesha or a median listing price around $300,000 in Menomonee Falls. Shorewood sits on the coast just minutes from Milwaukee and offers a median listing price around $200,000. All of these surrounding cities command higher home values than Milwaukee, but they also come with a more aggressive cost of living.

Milwaukee Property Managers

When you hire a property manager, you give them permission to take control of your rental property. Experienced managers can handle all aspects of property management, including advertising, tenant screening, accounting, hiring maintenance personnel and contracting for repair services. The manager should keep you updated on the property at regular intervals.

Milwaukee Property Management Company Fees

Most property managers in Wisconsin will charge about 10 percent of the gross rent collected from a rental property. This fee can vary, depending on the services included in the contract and any special needs of the property. Most managers will customize their services to meet the expectations of each client.

Wisconsin Landlord/Tenant Laws

  • Once a tenant moves out of a rental unit, the landlord has 21 days to return the tenant’s security deposit.
  • Wisconsin tenants have the right to file a lawsuit worth up to $10,000 when a landlord fails to return their security deposit or evicts them wrongfully.