Property Management
in Milwaukee, WI

Top 25 Property Management Companies

Companies who display the iPropertyManagement seal have demonstrated a high standard of excellence for both owners and tenants in the field of property management.

Wisconsin

License #: 700270

Bender Property Management

#1 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

No Reviews Found

414-535-9992
6622 W Fond Du Lac Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53218
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1995
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Pennybag Property Management

#2 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

262-719-1332
3728 N 36th St, Milwaukee, WI 53216
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 834967

Eastmore Real Estate Management, Inc

#3 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-961-1822
3287 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

$300 pet deposit ($100 non-refundable – for pet cleaning) *application fee of $20

License #: 834512

Milwaukee Property Management

#4 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 3 Reviews Show all

414-312-5001
611 W National Ave , #325 Milwaukee, Wi. 53204
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Schulhof Property Management LLC

#5 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-933-1211
825 N 16th St, Milwaukee, WI 53233
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: A+
Since 1997
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 937268

Structure Property Management

#6 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

Based on 2 Reviews Show all

414-882-8777
804 E Wright St, Milwaukee, WI 53212
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2013
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

GatoCity LLC

#7 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-403-8645
610 E Pleasant St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Jomela Properties

#8 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-442-1700
5601 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2003
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 2963

Benkowski Builders

#9 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 1 Reviews Show all

414-762-5400
1111 Milwaukee Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1953
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 937517

Citywide Rentals

#10 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-269-6446
9919 W Lisbon Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53222
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since 2013
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Sidello Property Services

#11 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 1 Reviews Show all

414-482-7476
4864 S 10th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1995
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Dominion Properties

#12 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 9 Reviews Show all

414-264-5901
2025 N SUMMIT AVE MILWAUKEE WI, 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2000
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 700381

NAI MLG Commercial

#13 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 3 Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-347-9400
757 N Broadway #700, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Areas Served Milwaukee
51-200 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1987
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 9852

Ogden & Company, Inc

#14 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-276-5285
1665 N Water St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee, Wauwatosa, WI, Chilton, WI,Franklin, WI, Mesa, AZ
51-200 employees BBB: A+
Since 1929
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 700458

Pentagon Property Management

#15 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-225-5800
732 N Jackson St # 300, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 2011
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 14224

Bieck Management

#16 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 12 Reviews Show all

414-961-7400
5205 N Ironwood Rd # 201, Milwaukee, WI 53217
Areas Served Milwaukee
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1977
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 700045-91

MPI Property Management

#17 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 5+ Reviews Show all

Based on 8 Reviews Show all

414-933-2700
6700 W Fairview Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53213
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: A+
Since 1978
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

ABC Management Inc

#18 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 2 Reviews Show all

No Reviews Found

414-225-3100
621 E Pleasant St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since 2008
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Bell Property Management Inc

#19 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

No Reviews Found

414-332-1117
2545 N Maryland Ave #102, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since 1998
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

$20 application fee per applicant *$100 deposit per cat. There is also a $25 monthly fee per cat

License #: 700477

TEAM Management, LLC

#20 best rated of 25 Milwaukee, WI property management companies

Based on 1 Review Show all

No Reviews Found

414-273-8326
3816 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Areas Served Milwaukee
1-10 employees BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

MKE PM

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-534-9391
2510 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Areas Served Milwaukee
? BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 936820

Siegel-Gallagher Management

No Reviews Found

No Reviews Found

414-270-4100
252 E Highland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee, Chicago, IL
11-50 employees BBB: N/A
Since 1995
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

The Management Group

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-444-1800
7430 West Harwood Avenue, Suite 200Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Areas Served Milwaukee,Wauwatosa, WI
? BBB: A+
Since 2008
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: 701546

Westbrook Management

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-270-0300
622 N Water St # 200, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Areas Served Milwaukee
51-200 employees BBB: N/A
Since ?
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

License #: ?

Zilber Limited

No Reviews Found Show all

No Reviews Found

414-274-2400
710 N Plankinton Ave # 1200, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Areas Served Milwaukee
51-200 employees BBB: A+
Since 1948
Residential
Commercial
Hoa

?

Milwaukee vs Nearby Cities

Real estate prices in Milwaukee are surprisingly affordable, especially when compared to home prices in many surrounding cities. Positioned on the eastern coastline of Wisconsin, this city offers a median listing price below $150,000 much of the time. Compare that to a median listing price close to $250,000 in Waukesha or a median listing price around $300,000 in Menomonee Falls. Shorewood sits on the coast just minutes from Milwaukee and offers a median listing price around $200,000. All of these surrounding cities command higher home values than Milwaukee, but they also come with a more aggressive cost of living.

Milwaukee Property Managers

When you hire a property manager, you give them permission to take control of your rental property. Experienced managers can handle all aspects of property management, including advertising, tenant screening, accounting, hiring maintenance personnel and contracting for repair services. The manager should keep you updated on the property at regular intervals.

Milwaukee Property Management Company Fees

Most property managers in Wisconsin will charge about 10 percent of the gross rent collected from a rental property. This fee can vary, depending on the services included in the contract and any special needs of the property. Most managers will customize their services to meet the expectations of each client.

Wisconsin Landlord/Tenant Laws

  • Once a tenant moves out of a rental unit, the landlord has 21 days to return the tenant’s security deposit.
  • Wisconsin tenants have the right to file a lawsuit worth up to $10,000 when a landlord fails to return their security deposit or evicts them wrongfully.